24-70mm Showdown - Nikon F vs Z vs Tamron vs Sigma Art

Matt Granger

Matt Granger

13 min, 9 sec

A detailed hands-on comparison of Nikon F-mount, Tamron G2, Sigma Art, and Z mount 24-70mm lenses, including image quality, tracking, low-light performance, and price considerations.

Summary

  • Tested Nikon F-mount, Tamron G2, Sigma Art, and Z mount 24-70mm lenses using various cameras and settings.
  • Nikon's F-mount lens shows age with no clear advantage; Tamron G2 offers significant value for its price.
  • Sigma Art lens is heavier, more expensive, and optically slightly behind Tamron and Nikon F-mount.
  • Z mount lens excels in performance, autofocus speed, and image quality but comes at a higher price.

Chapter 1

Introduction to the Lens Showdown

0:01 - 26 sec

Introduction to the comparison of Nikon F-mount, Z mount, Tamron G2, and Sigma Art 24-70mm lenses.

Introduction to the comparison of Nikon F-mount, Z mount, Tamron G2, and Sigma Art 24-70mm lenses.

  • Announced a showdown comparing Nikon F-mount, Z mount, Tamron G2, and Sigma Art lenses.
  • Mentioned an image quality comparison had been done previously.
  • Highlighted the intention to update the comparison due to lens updates.

Chapter 2

Sponsorship Mention

0:38 - 46 sec

A brief interlude to mention the video's sponsor, Nord VPN.

A brief interlude to mention the video's sponsor, Nord VPN.

  • Mentioned using Nord VPN for over 18 months, highlighting its benefits.
  • Offered a discount code for Nord VPN with a bonus month.

Chapter 3

Overview of Test Approach

1:23 - 26 sec

Outline of the hands-on test approach for comparing the lenses.

Outline of the hands-on test approach for comparing the lenses.

  • Explained the video will be hands-on with practical shoots to test various lens capabilities.
  • Advised viewers to check the description for full specifications and pricing links.

Chapter 4

Detailed Lens Specifications

1:49 - 2 min, 55 sec

Detailed specifications of each lens being compared in the showdown.

Detailed specifications of each lens being compared in the showdown.

  • Discussed the Nikon 24-70 F-mount non-VR version's age, price, weight, and lens construction.
  • Evaluated the Tamron G2's build quality, price, weight, and lens elements.
  • Reviewed the Sigma Art's build, weight, price, and lens complexity.
  • Outlined the Nikon Z mount's features, weight, lens elements, price, and lack of in-lens stabilization.

Chapter 5

Studio Shoot Setup

4:44 - 1 min, 7 sec

Setting up a studio shoot with different backdrops and lighting for the lens comparison.

Setting up a studio shoot with different backdrops and lighting for the lens comparison.

  • Chose a gold-themed backdrop for the shoot.
  • Set up the lighting and had the model maintain a consistent pose for repeatable results.

Chapter 6

Outdoor Shoot Setup

5:51 - 1 min, 7 sec

Conducting an outdoor shoot using the same lighting setup for lens comparison.

Conducting an outdoor shoot using the same lighting setup for lens comparison.

  • Moved outdoors to shoot in front of Manhattan, adjusting the scene and light settings.
  • Took shots with each lens at the same settings to maintain consistency.

Chapter 7

Lens Focal Length Comparison

6:58 - 23 sec

Noticed a difference in focal length portrayal between the lenses at 70mm.

Noticed a difference in focal length portrayal between the lenses at 70mm.

  • Observed that the new Nikon lenses appear longer at 70mm compared to Tamron and Sigma.
  • Suggested that the Nikon lenses may be longer than 70mm, or the others could be shorter.

Chapter 8

Movement and Low-Light Tests

7:21 - 1 min, 25 sec

Performing movement and low-light tests to evaluate the tracking and focusing capabilities.

Performing movement and low-light tests to evaluate the tracking and focusing capabilities.

  • Conducted a movement test by having the model run back and forth while tracking with each lens.
  • Turned off studio lights for a low-light focus test at ISO 12800.

Chapter 9

Final Thoughts and Recommendations

8:46 - 4 min, 20 sec

Final evaluation and recommendations based on the comparison tests.

Final evaluation and recommendations based on the comparison tests.

  • Concluded that Nikon's F-mount lens is outdated and Tamron G2 offers great value for its price.
  • Sigma Art lens is heavier and not recommended over the others unless brand loyalty is a factor.
  • Z mount lens has the best performance but at a higher cost, making it a choice for those with a higher budget.
  • For budget-conscious buyers, Tamron is the recommended option.