Alarming trend: Scientific fraud is on the rise -- and I fear it will become worse

Sabine Hossenfelder

Sabine Hossenfelder

7 min, 56 sec

The video discusses the increasing issue of fraudulent scientific papers and the challenges in combating this trend, including the role of AI and paper mills.

Summary

  • Science is facing an issue with an increasing number of fraudulent papers, exacerbated by recent AI advancements.
  • The speaker shares a personal solution to managing paper annotations using the Remarkable tablet.
  • Nature magazine data shows a record number of retracted papers in 2023, most due to fraud rather than honest mistakes.
  • Special issues in journals and paper mills are significant sources of fraudulent publications, often in fields like drug development.
  • Attempts at bribery and peer-review manipulation are rising, threatening the integrity of scientific publications.

Chapter 1

The Growing Problem with Scientific Papers

0:01 - 16 sec

The video opens with an overview of the significant problem science faces due to an increase in fraudulent scientific papers.

The video opens with an overview of the significant problem science faces due to an increase in fraudulent scientific papers.

  • Science is facing a big problem with fraudulent papers, worsened by AI advances.
  • Fraudulent papers are being published more aggressively and frequently.

Chapter 2

Personal Anecdote and Remarkable Tablet Solution

0:28 - 1 min, 12 sec

The speaker shares a personal anecdote about the inconvenience of annotating scientific papers and how the Remarkable tablet has been a solution.

The speaker shares a personal anecdote about the inconvenience of annotating scientific papers and how the Remarkable tablet has been a solution.

  • The speaker dislikes annotating papers digitally and used to print them out.
  • A year ago, the speaker switched to using the Remarkable tablet, enhancing workflow and organization.

Chapter 3

Surge in Retracted Papers

1:43 - 47 sec

Nature magazine's data indicates a record number of retracted papers in 2023, with most being fraudulent.

Nature magazine's data indicates a record number of retracted papers in 2023, with most being fraudulent.

  • Over 10,000 papers were retracted in 2023, a record high, with the majority containing fraud.
  • Retractions are increasing faster than publication numbers, with about two per thousand papers retracted.

Chapter 4

Special Issues in Publishing

2:37 - 57 sec

Special issues in journals have become problematic, often serving as repositories for scam papers.

Special issues in journals have become problematic, often serving as repositories for scam papers.

  • Most retractions occur in countries like Saudi Arabia and from publishers like Hindavi, often in special issues.
  • Special issues were intended for collections on specific topics but have become junkyards for guaranteed publications.

Chapter 5

The Dangers of Paper Mills

4:26 - 1 min, 16 sec

Paper mills produce and guide scam papers to publication, posing a significant threat to public health and scientific integrity.

Paper mills produce and guide scam papers to publication, posing a significant threat to public health and scientific integrity.

  • Paper mills offer authorship on papers for money, a practice originating in China and spreading globally.
  • These mills often produce papers in areas like drug development, supporting ineffective drugs with fake citations.

Chapter 6

Bribery and Peer-Review Manipulation

6:25 - 1 min, 22 sec

Bribery of journal editors and manipulation of the peer-review process are on the rise, indicating a deep-seated issue in scientific publishing.

Bribery of journal editors and manipulation of the peer-review process are on the rise, indicating a deep-seated issue in scientific publishing.

  • Instances of bribery to accept manuscripts and peer-review manipulations, including AI-generated reviews, are increasing.
  • The problem affects even well-known publishers, driven by a system that values publication quantity over quality.

Chapter 7

Closing Remarks

7:45 - 9 sec

The video concludes with thoughts on the future of science in the face of AI and fraudulent activities.

The video concludes with thoughts on the future of science in the face of AI and fraudulent activities.

  • AI's advancements may lead to more fraud in scientific disciplines, making it harder to identify.
  • The speaker questions whether leaving science to AI entirely might be better.

More Sabine Hossenfelder summaries

Is Nuclear Energy Green?

Is Nuclear Energy Green?

Sabine Hossenfelder

Sabine Hossenfelder

The video explores the pros and cons of nuclear power, detailing its impact on the environment, economy, and public perception.

Our new research found that dark matter is probably right | Science News

Our new research found that dark matter is probably right | Science News

Sabine Hossenfelder

Sabine Hossenfelder

The video discusses the astrophysics controversy regarding the existence of Dark Matter versus the need to change the law of gravity, focusing on a new study comparing the two theories.

String Theory Nonsense Makes Comeback | Science News

String Theory Nonsense Makes Comeback | Science News

Sabine Hossenfelder

Sabine Hossenfelder

An in-depth explanation of the concept of dark dimensions in string theory and their proposed link to dark matter.

Rapid AI Progress Surprises Even Experts: Survey just out

Rapid AI Progress Surprises Even Experts: Survey just out

Sabine Hossenfelder

Sabine Hossenfelder

The video discusses a survey among AI experts regarding the acceleration of AI development and its impact on society, including job automation and the potential risks of superintelligent AI.

Q-Day Is Coming: Quantum Computers Will Decode National Secrets

Q-Day Is Coming: Quantum Computers Will Decode National Secrets

Sabine Hossenfelder

Sabine Hossenfelder

The video discusses the potential impact of quantum computing on internet security, particularly the risks associated with Q-Day, when quantum computers may break current encryption protocols.