Best Screwdriver Set? Craftsman, Milwaukee, Wera, Wiha, Klein Tools, Felo, PB Swiss, Tekton

Project Farm

Project Farm

15 min, 8 sec

A comprehensive comparison of various screwdriver brands, including their performance in driving and removing screws, resistance to cam out and failure load, handling of hammer blows, chemical resistance, and value for money.

Summary

  • Different brands of screwdrivers are tested for various capabilities such as their ability to drive and remove screws, handle hammer blows, and their resistance to cam out and failure loads.
  • The brands tested include Pittsburgh, Craftsman, Tecton, Channel Lock, Filo, Milwaukee, Wera, Vessel, Klein Tools, PB Swiss, and Wiha.
  • The screwdrivers are also tested for chemical resistance using brake parts cleaner.
  • The overall performance of each brand is evaluated, considering their price and performance.
  • Wera and PB Swiss performed the best overall but are quite expensive. Milwaukee and Wearer offered good performance at a more moderate price point, while Craftsman is recommended for those on a tight budget.

Chapter 1

Introduction and Testing Overview

0:00 - 18 sec

The video introduces different brands of screwdrivers to be tested and outlines the tests that will be carried out.

The video introduces different brands of screwdrivers to be tested and outlines the tests that will be carried out.

  • The screwdrivers are to be tested for their ability to drive and remove screws, handle hammer blows, and their resistance to cam out and failure loads.
  • Brands tested include Pittsburgh, Craftsman, Tecton, Channel Lock, Filo, Milwaukee, Wera, Vessel, Klein Tools, PB Swiss, and Wiha.
  • The first test involves driving in and removing 50 screws with each screwdriver.

Chapter 2

Evaluation of the Screwdrivers' Performance in Driving and Removing Screws

0:17 - 7 min, 1 sec

Each screwdriver is evaluated based on their performance in driving and removing 50 screws.

Each screwdriver is evaluated based on their performance in driving and removing 50 screws.

  • The brands are tested one by one, starting with the least expensive, Pittsburgh, which runs out of steam on the 11th screw.
  • The Craftsman brand manages to install and remove 50 screws, but the screwdriver flutes are nearly used up.
  • Tecton performs well initially, but soon requires significant downward force to keep the screwdriver from slipping out of the screw.
  • Channel Lock, Filo, Milwaukee, Wera, Vessel, Klein Tools, PB Swiss, and Wiha all perform well, with varying levels of wear on the screwdriver flutes.

Chapter 3

Testing for Failure or Cam Out Load

7:18 - 3 min, 48 sec

The screwdrivers are tested for their resistance to failure or cam out load.

The screwdrivers are tested for their resistance to failure or cam out load.

  • This test measures how much torque each screwdriver can handle before it fails or cams out.
  • The brands perform as follows: Pittsburgh at 79 inch pounds, Craftsman at 118 inch pounds, Tecton at 90 inch pounds, Channel Lock at 95 inch pounds, Filo at 117 inch pounds, Milwaukee at 127 inch pounds, Wera at 131 inch pounds, Vessel at 123 inch pounds, Klein Tools at 85 inch pounds, PB Swiss at 136 inch pounds, and Wiha at 115 inch pounds.
  • PB Swiss comes out on top, followed closely by Wera.

Chapter 4

Testing the Screwdrivers' Strength Against Hammer Blows

11:06 - 1 min, 50 sec

Each screwdriver is tested for how well it handles the stress of hammer blows.

Each screwdriver is tested for how well it handles the stress of hammer blows.

  • The screwdrivers are struck with a hammer and tested for failure load using a hydraulic press.
  • Different brands of screwdrivers perform differently under the pressure, with some bending while others break.
  • Tecton, Klein, and Milwaukee, all American brands, perform the best, while the German brand Wiha and the Japanese brand Vessel also perform well.

Chapter 5

Testing the Screwdrivers for Chemical Resistance

12:57 - 26 sec

The screwdrivers are tested for their resistance to chemicals.

The screwdrivers are tested for their resistance to chemicals.

  • The screwdriver handles are dipped in brake parts cleaner for one minute.
  • All brands survive the test, but Craftsman and Channel Lock's plastic handles become soft.
  • None of the handles become sticky after exposure to the cleaner.

Chapter 6

Final Evaluation and Recommendations

13:23 - 1 min, 46 sec

The brands are evaluated in terms of their overall performance and value for money.

The brands are evaluated in terms of their overall performance and value for money.

  • Wera and PB Swiss perform the best but are quite expensive.
  • Milwaukee and Wearer offer good performance at a more moderate price point.
  • For those on a tight budget, Craftsman is recommended as it offers decent performance at a relatively low price.

More Project Farm summaries

10 Best Products Tested in 2023? Let’s Find Out!

10 Best Products Tested in 2023? Let’s Find Out!

Project Farm

Project Farm

A detailed rundown of the top 10 best products for 2023, featuring tests, comparisons, and analyses across various categories.

Which AA Rechargeable Battery is Best after 1 Year?  Let's find out! Eneloop, Duracell, Amazon, EBL

Which AA Rechargeable Battery is Best after 1 Year? Let's find out! Eneloop, Duracell, Amazon, EBL

Project Farm

Project Farm

A detailed analysis of different brands of double-A rechargeable batteries after one year of use and one year of storage, including tests for capacity, self-discharge, and internal resistance.