Criminal Lawyer Reacts to Dad Is SICKENED By Killer Son's Confession

CLR Bruce Rivers

CLR Bruce Rivers

124 min, 9 sec

A comprehensive examination of the murder of Michaela Costanzo, revealing the involvement of Cody Patton and Toni Fratto and the sequence of events that led to Michaela's tragic death.

Summary

  • Cody Patton initially fabricates stories during interrogation, but his narrative is contradicted by evidence including tire tracks, blood samples, and school surveillance footage.
  • Tony Fratto, Cody's girlfriend, initially appears uninvolved but later reveals her participation in the murder, exposing her jealousy and obsession with Michaela from diary entries.
  • Both Cody and Tony admit to the murder but blame each other for the final act. Cody's private investigator uncovers additional evidence against Tony.
  • Cody Patton pleads guilty to first-degree murder and receives a life sentence without parole; Toni Fratto takes a plea deal for second-degree murder and testifies against Cody, receiving a life sentence with the possibility of parole after 18 years.

Chapter 1

Initial Interrogation and Cody Patton's Fabrications

75:45 - 1 min, 1 sec

Cody Patton's fabricated stories during initial interrogation are exposed by evidence.

Cody Patton's fabricated stories during initial interrogation are exposed by evidence.

  • Cody Patton presents false narratives and accusations during police interrogation.
  • Investigators uncover contradictions in Cody's stories through tire tracks, DNA evidence, and surveillance footage.
  • Despite Cody's denial, evidence suggests he followed Michaela out of school, contradicting his statement of being elsewhere.

Chapter 2

Toni Fratto's Involvement and Obsession

75:47 - 1 min, 59 sec

Tony Fratto's deep-seated insecurities and hatred for Michaela are revealed.

Tony Fratto's deep-seated insecurities and hatred for Michaela are revealed.

  • Tony Fratto admits to participating in Michaela's murder and blames Cody for instigating the crime.
  • Diary entries found in Tony's bedroom expose her obsession with Michaela and her fear that Cody would leave her.
  • Tony's statements and diary entries establish her motive for the crime.

Chapter 3

Cody Patton's Confession and Shifting Blame

77:50 - 1 min, 17 sec

Cody Patton confesses to the murder and tries to shift blame onto Tony Fratto.

Cody Patton confesses to the murder and tries to shift blame onto Tony Fratto.

  • Cody confesses to killing Michaela but claims it was spontaneous and not planned.
  • He later changes his story, admitting to more involvement in the murder, and implicates Tony in the process.
  • Cody's legal team employs a private investigator who uncovers evidence against Tony.

Chapter 4

The Final Act of Betrayal

79:07 - 53 sec

Cody turns on Tony, leading to her arrest and revealing the true extent of their crime.

Cody turns on Tony, leading to her arrest and revealing the true extent of their crime.

  • Cody allows his legal team to gather evidence against Tony, leading to her arrest.
  • Tony's confession to the attorney confirms her participation and exposes her motive.
  • Evidence from Tony's bedroom suggests premeditation and a possible setup to murder Michaela.

Chapter 5

Sentencing and Aftermath

80:00 - 59 sec

Cody Patton and Toni Fratto receive their sentences for the murder of Michaela Costanzo.

Cody Patton and Toni Fratto receive their sentences for the murder of Michaela Costanzo.

  • Cody Patton pleads guilty to first-degree murder and is sentenced to life without parole.
  • Tony Fratto takes a plea deal for second-degree murder and is sentenced to life with the possibility of parole after 18 years.
  • Tony's parole is denied in 2021, with her next hearing scheduled for May 2024.