Do Spacecraft Really Have To Endure The Hazards of Reentry

Scott Manley

Scott Manley

12 min, 23 sec

Scott Manley discusses the challenges of re-entry heat management for spacecraft returning from space missions.

Summary

  • Scott Manley analyzes the video footage from the Aran capsule during the EMIS-1 mission re-entry, noting the visible glow from atmospheric heating.
  • He explains the kinetic energy involved in re-entry from the moon at speeds over 11 km/s and the necessity of heat shields for spacecraft.
  • Manley addresses questions about alternative methods to avoid re-entry heating, such as slowing down in orbit or gliding through the atmosphere at high altitudes.
  • He uses the rocket equation to demonstrate the impracticality of slowing down using propulsion due to the mass of propellant required.
  • The video also covers the limitations of lift-to-drag ratios in spacecraft design, the role of aerobraking, and the possibility of using inflatable heat shields for future missions.

Chapter 1

Introduction to Re-entry Video Analysis

0:04 - 19 sec

Scott Manley introduces a re-entry video from the EMIS-1 mission featuring the Aran capsule.

Scott Manley introduces a re-entry video from the EMIS-1 mission featuring the Aran capsule.

  • Manley finds the inclusion of audio in the re-entry footage captivating, with sounds of thruster firings and re-entry heating audible.
  • The video shows the spacecraft glows due to the heat generated as it re-enters Earth's atmosphere from the moon.

Chapter 2

Kinetic Energy and Heat Shields

0:23 - 45 sec

Exploration of the kinetic energy involved in spacecraft re-entry and the role of heat shields.

Exploration of the kinetic energy involved in spacecraft re-entry and the role of heat shields.

  • During re-entry from the moon, a spacecraft travels over 11 km/s, and each kilogram of it holds about 60 mega joules of energy.
  • The intense energy causes the air around the spacecraft to glow, indicating that energy is being dissipated into the atmosphere rather than the spacecraft itself.
  • Heat shields are crucial for protecting spacecraft and future human passengers from the massive energy encountered during re-entry.

Chapter 3

Alternative Re-entry Methods Discussion

1:08 - 15 sec

Manley discusses two commonly proposed alternative methods for re-entry to avoid intense heating.

Manley discusses two commonly proposed alternative methods for re-entry to avoid intense heating.

  • The first idea is to slow the spacecraft down in orbit to reduce re-entry speeds, and the second is to have a winged vehicle glide at high altitudes before re-entering.
  • Both ideas are well-intentioned but not feasible according to Manley, and the following explanations are provided to support his claim.

Chapter 4

Issues with Slowing Down in Orbit

1:23 - 17 sec

Manley explains why slowing down the spacecraft in orbit is impractical using the rocket equation.

Manley explains why slowing down the spacecraft in orbit is impractical using the rocket equation.

  • Slowing down a spacecraft by 5 km/s in orbit would require a significant amount of propellant, making the method impractical compared to using a heat shield.
  • The rocket equation shows that for a 10-ton spacecraft, you would need an additional 42 tons of propellant to slow down sufficiently for a safer re-entry.

Chapter 5

The Challenge of Gliding in the Atmosphere

1:40 - 37 sec

Manley addresses the concept of using a winged vehicle to glide in the atmosphere for re-entry.

Manley addresses the concept of using a winged vehicle to glide in the atmosphere for re-entry.

  • Gliding at high altitudes is limited by the spacecraft's lift-to-drag ratio, which determines how much energy it must dissipate during descent.
  • The space shuttle, for example, had a modest lift-to-drag ratio, leading to significant heating even with a controlled glide through the atmosphere.

Chapter 6

Aerodynamics and Re-entry Physics

2:16 - 25 sec

Further discussion on aerodynamics and physics involved in spacecraft re-entry.

Further discussion on aerodynamics and physics involved in spacecraft re-entry.

  • Aerobraking can be used for gradually reducing orbit, but once velocity is lower than low Earth orbit, a spacecraft must commit to re-entry.
  • The lift generated by a vehicle during re-entry must balance the gravitational pull, which in turn creates drag and leads to heating.

Chapter 7

Exploring the Lift-to-Drag Ratio

2:42 - 35 sec

An explanation of the lift-to-drag ratio and its implications for spacecraft design.

An explanation of the lift-to-drag ratio and its implications for spacecraft design.

  • Different vehicles have varying lift-to-drag ratios, with gliders achieving very high ratios and space capsules having ratios of less than one.
  • Crafts with higher lift-to-drag ratios can glide for longer, but they still generate significant heat that must be managed.

Chapter 8

Theoretical Limits of Lift-to-Drag Ratios

3:17 - 39 sec

Manley discusses the theoretical limits of lift-to-drag ratios for spacecraft.

Manley discusses the theoretical limits of lift-to-drag ratios for spacecraft.

  • Increasing the lift-to-drag ratio can reduce the temperature of the spacecraft during re-entry, but not sufficiently to eliminate the need for heat shields.
  • The shape of the spacecraft affects its aerodynamics and heating, with pointy shapes experiencing more heating than rounded ones.

Chapter 9

Inflatable Heat Shield Technology

3:56 - 32 sec

Manley introduces the concept of inflatable heat shields and their potential benefits for future space missions.

Manley introduces the concept of inflatable heat shields and their potential benefits for future space missions.

  • Inflatable heat shields could significantly reduce re-entry heating by increasing the surface area and creating a larger buffer between the spacecraft and the hot re-entry plasma.
  • The successful LOFTID experiment demonstrated the feasibility of inflatable heat shields for deceleration in orbit and potential recovery of rocket engines.

Chapter 10

Concept of a Space Zeppelin

4:27 - 7 min, 20 sec

Manley explores the idea of a 'space Zeppelin' as an alternative spacecraft design.

Manley explores the idea of a 'space Zeppelin' as an alternative spacecraft design.

  • A space Zeppelin would feature an expanded surface area to keep the heating layer away from the spacecraft's surface, potentially eliminating the need for a heat shield.
  • JP Aerospace's Airship to Orbit concept suggests that such a space Zeppelin could be feasible for careful orbital ascent and re-entry.

Chapter 11

Conclusion on Re-entry Heating

11:47 - 12 sec

Manley concludes that re-entry heating is an unavoidable aspect of space travel that must be managed.

Manley concludes that re-entry heating is an unavoidable aspect of space travel that must be managed.

  • Despite various ideas and theoretical possibilities, re-entry heating is a challenge that cannot be easily circumvented through propulsion or aerodynamics.
  • Manley emphasizes that managing re-entry heat remains a complex problem, requiring sophisticated solutions like heat shields.

Chapter 12

Video Outro

12:00 - 22 sec

The video ends with Scott Manley signing off and music playing.

The video ends with Scott Manley signing off and music playing.

  • Scott Manley concludes the video with his signature sign-off, encouraging safe flying.