How Can We Bear to Throw Anything Away?

Jacob Geller

Jacob Geller

40 min, 40 sec

The video discusses the challenges of preserving video game history, the impermanence of digital content, and the personal conflict over data hoarding.

Summary

  • The speaker shares experiences of seeing early builds of video games under NDA and contemplates the loss of unique development paths.
  • Discusses the rare instances where game studios preserve and share the evolution of games, such as through documentaries or art books.
  • Highlights the issue of video game availability, with 87% of classic games being inaccessible, likening the situation to the loss of historical audio recordings and silent films.
  • The speaker reflects on the compulsion to hoard digital content and the challenges faced by institutions and individuals in preserving digital history.
  • Examines the broader implications of digital preservation, data hoarding, and the cultural and emotional significance of maintaining collections.

Chapter 1

Experience with Pre-Release Video Games

0:00 - 1 min, 47 sec

The speaker discusses their experiences viewing pre-release video games and the transient nature of development paths not taken.

The speaker discusses their experiences viewing pre-release video games and the transient nature of development paths not taken.

  • The speaker has seen early builds of unreleased games under strict NDAs and is prohibited from discussing specifics.
  • In-progress games often feel incomplete with placeholder elements, but sometimes offer a glimpse into potential development directions.
  • The speaker expresses a desire to preserve these unique moments of game development.

Chapter 2

The Rarity of Preserved Game Development Insights

1:47 - 55 sec

The rarity of preserved insights into game development and the speaker's wish for more comprehensive documentation.

The rarity of preserved insights into game development and the speaker's wish for more comprehensive documentation.

  • Instances of game studios preserving the game development process are rare and usually incomplete.
  • The speaker wishes for a similar level of insight into the development of iconic games like Shadow of the Colossus or Super Metroid.
  • There is a recognition that future research is limited by the choices of past documentarians and what studios choose to preserve.

Chapter 3

Impulse to Preserve and Video Game History at Risk

2:42 - 2 min, 4 sec

The speaker's impulse to preserve game history and the precarious state of video game preservation.

The speaker's impulse to preserve game history and the precarious state of video game preservation.

  • The speaker feels an urge to save digital content but acknowledges the legal and practical limitations of doing so.
  • There is a reliance on individuals who risk breaking the law to preserve video game history.
  • The Video Game History Foundation reports that the vast majority of classic games are unavailable, posing a threat to their preservation.

Chapter 4

Struggles with Digital Content Accessibility

4:46 - 2 min, 39 sec

The speaker's internal conflict over the accessibility of digital content and the impermanence of online platforms.

The speaker's internal conflict over the accessibility of digital content and the impermanence of online platforms.

  • The speaker questions the historical value of some games and the overwhelming volume of digital content being produced.
  • They reflect on the ease of digital hoarding and the paradox of seemingly limitless storage capacity.

Chapter 5

Digital Hoarding and Data Preservation Culture

7:24 - 3 min, 7 sec

Exploring the culture of digital hoarding and the challenges associated with preserving vast amounts of data.

Exploring the culture of digital hoarding and the challenges associated with preserving vast amounts of data.

  • The subreddit r/datahoarder showcases individuals who collect and preserve large amounts of data, reflecting a widespread anxiety about losing information.
  • The story illustrates the futility of attempting to preserve an overwhelming volume of information.

Chapter 6

The Paradox of Encyclopedic Knowledge

10:31 - 3 min, 41 sec

The paradox of the pursuit of encyclopedic knowledge and the limitations of historical preservation.

The paradox of the pursuit of encyclopedic knowledge and the limitations of historical preservation.

  • Historical encyclopedias, while attempting to compile all knowledge, inevitably fail to be comprehensive and often lose their value over time.
  • The speaker draws parallels between past efforts to gather all knowledge and present-day digital preservation.

Chapter 7

The Ephemeral Nature of Digital and Physical Knowledge

14:12 - 5 min, 58 sec

The ephemeral nature of both digital knowledge and physical encyclopedias, and the challenges of lasting preservation.

The ephemeral nature of both digital knowledge and physical encyclopedias, and the challenges of lasting preservation.

  • The speaker contrasts the longevity of physical encyclopedias with the 22-year lifespan of Wikipedia and questions the durability of digital preservation.
  • They discuss the Internet Archive's massive effort to digitally preserve knowledge.

Chapter 8

The Internet Archive and the Definition of a 'Hoard'

20:10 - 2 min, 36 sec

The role of the Internet Archive in preservation and the blurred line between a collection and a hoard.

The role of the Internet Archive in preservation and the blurred line between a collection and a hoard.

  • The Internet Archive aims to archive all digital content, raising questions about the difference between an archive and a hoard.
  • The distinction between a valuable collection and a hoard is often only clear in hindsight.

Chapter 9

The Emotional Significance of Collections

22:46 - 2 min, 25 sec

The emotional significance of collections and the struggle to balance attachment with practicality.

The emotional significance of collections and the struggle to balance attachment with practicality.

  • The speaker reflects on the emotional reasons behind their grandmother's extensive collection of books and other items.
  • They contemplate the value of physical media and the reliability of digital platforms.

Chapter 10

Marion Stokes and the Value of Preservation

25:11 - 1 min, 19 sec

Marion Stokes's extensive news archive and the fine line between a valuable collection and a hoard.

Marion Stokes's extensive news archive and the fine line between a valuable collection and a hoard.

  • Marion Stokes recorded 35 years of news footage, creating a unique historical archive.
  • The speaker explores the personal cost of Stokes's dedication and the societal value of her collection.

Chapter 11

The Challenge of Curating Content

26:30 - 2 min, 8 sec

The personal challenge of curating content and deciding what to keep in the face of overwhelming digital proliferation.

The personal challenge of curating content and deciding what to keep in the face of overwhelming digital proliferation.

  • The speaker discusses the difficulty in curating the vast amount of information for the video.
  • They express the challenge of balancing the desire to preserve with the need to let go.

Chapter 12

Family Legacies and the Impermanence of Collections

28:38 - 5 min, 40 sec

The speaker reflects on family legacies, the impermanence of collections, and the challenge of determining value.

The speaker reflects on family legacies, the impermanence of collections, and the challenge of determining value.

  • The speaker's grandmother disposes of encyclopedias, revealing hidden family artifacts.
  • The speaker ponders the true value of items kept and the difficulty in discerning what should be preserved.

Chapter 13

The Complexity of Value and Memory in Collections

34:18 - 47 sec

The complexity of ascribing value to collections and the role of memory and history in attachment to items.

The complexity of ascribing value to collections and the role of memory and history in attachment to items.

  • The speaker acknowledges the oversimplification of valuing items solely by emotional attachment.
  • They recognize the intricate relationship between historical preservation, individual effort, and emotional connections.

Chapter 14

Katamari Damacy and the Collection Metaphor

35:05 - 1 min, 0 sec

The speaker draws a metaphor between the game Katamari Damacy and the compulsion to collect and preserve.

The speaker draws a metaphor between the game Katamari Damacy and the compulsion to collect and preserve.

  • Katamari Damacy symbolizes the act of rolling up everything on Earth into a collection that is then judged and discarded.
  • The game serves as a metaphor for the speaker's reflections on the challenges of preserving digital content.

Chapter 15

Sponsor Message for Henson Razors

36:05 - 2 min, 48 sec

A sponsor message for Henson Razors, highlighting the product's quality and lifetime use.

A sponsor message for Henson Razors, highlighting the product's quality and lifetime use.

  • The speaker promotes Henson Razors as a durable and cost-effective shaving option.
  • They share a personal endorsement of the product and offer a promotion for free blades.

More Jacob Geller summaries

The Best Ten Games of 2023

The Best Ten Games of 2023

Jacob Geller

Jacob Geller

A detailed reflection on the video games played in 2023, highlighting favorites, industry trends, and personal gaming experiences.

Fear of Cold

Fear of Cold

Jacob Geller

Jacob Geller

The video explores the nature of cold, its impact on humans and the environment, and its depiction in literature and media.