How to restore trust in politics
The Economist
8 min, 10 sec
The video discusses the crisis in democratic trust and explores the potential of citizens assemblies as a solution to foster more engaged and impactful political participation.
Summary
- Democracy is experiencing a trust crisis with increasing polarization.
- Citizens assemblies, reflective of society's cross-section, are being piloted in Scotland to tackle pressing issues.
- Deliberative democracy, which citizens assemblies embody, is gaining traction globally with evidence of its effectiveness.
- Iceland's successful citizens assembly on abortion is highlighted as a case study.
- The biggest challenge is politicians' reluctance to cede control and genuinely empower these assemblies.
Chapter 1
Chapter 2
The video suggests revisiting an ancient idea to transform the citizen-politician relationship and enhance political engagement.
- The video proposes rebooting an ancient idea to improve citizen engagement in politics.
- This could change the relationship between citizens and politicians.
Chapter 3
The video introduces Shirley Islam, a participant in Scotland's citizens assembly, and explains how the assembly functions.
- Shirley Islam from Glasgow participates in a project bringing people closer to political decision making.
- The citizens assembly consists of a diverse group discussing issues and making recommendations to the government.
Chapter 4
Details on the meetings of the citizens assembly and the topics they have addressed are provided.
- Members of the assembly have met four times since 2019 and continue online during the pandemic.
- They've considered reforms such as drug laws and taxing wealth for a greener economy.
Chapter 5
The video features Matthew Taylor, a proponent of deliberative democracy, discussing its potential to restore trust in politicians.
- Matthew Taylor, an advocate for deliberative democracy, believes it could reverse the decline in trust for politicians.
- Deliberation can empower citizens, increasing their respect and responsibility.
Chapter 6
The video explores the positive effects of citizens assemblies on participants and the political process.
- Citizens assemblies can make participants feel empowered and sympathetic towards decision-makers.
- These assemblies may serve as an antidote to the adversarial nature of current politics.
Chapter 7
The video discusses the increasing implementation of deliberative processes worldwide and their influence on policy.
- Deliberative democracy is gaining popularity, with an increase in processes among OECD countries and the EU.
- Evidence shows that public authorities often implement recommendations from citizens assemblies.
Chapter 8
Iceland's citizens assembly on abortion legislation is showcased as a success story, influencing significant legislative change.
- Iceland's citizens assembly on abortion legislation helped the country navigate a polarizing issue.
- The assembly's recommendations led to a referendum where two-thirds voted for abortion rights.
Chapter 9
The video highlights challenges facing citizens assemblies, including representation issues and political resistance.
- Criticism arises when citizens assemblies do not represent the population accurately.
- Politicians' reluctance to embrace this model is a major obstacle to meaningful democratic change.
Chapter 10
The video concludes by contemplating the future of deliberative democracy and its integration into democratic systems.
- Deliberative democracy could become a key component of our political systems.
- The transition depends on politicians' willingness to share power and validate the influence of citizens assemblies.
Chapter 11
The video closes with an invitation to learn more about citizens assemblies and watch more videos from the series.
- Emma Hogan, deputy briefings editor at The Economist, invites viewers to read an article on citizens assemblies.
- Viewers are also encouraged to watch more videos from the series and to subscribe.
More The Economist summaries
Why it's harder to earn more than your parents
The Economist
The video discusses the difficulties in achieving social mobility in modern society, the role of education, and the impact of one's birth class on life opportunities.