How U.S. diplomats learn languages | FSI language courses review

The video discusses the time it takes to learn different languages based on the Foreign Service Institute's categorization, factors affecting language learning difficulty, and realistic expectations for achieving fluency.

Summary

  • The speaker addresses the FSI's classification of languages by difficulty and estimated study time to reach a certain proficiency level, with specific reference to English speakers.
  • He provides a detailed critique of the FSI's language categories, questioning the accuracy of the timescales and difficulty levels, particularly for category one languages.
  • The speaker highlights factors both inherent to languages and external, such as the learner's motivation and availability of learning materials, that influence the ease or difficulty of language learning.
  • He suggests that while the FSI's estimates may not guarantee reaching a B2 level, they can provide a strong foundation for continued language learning.
  • Personal experience with different languages and their learning processes is used to reflect on the FSI's methodology and the realistic outcomes of language study.

Chapter 1

Introduction to Language Learning Time

0:00 - 20 sec

The speaker introduces the topic of language learning time estimates and references the US Foreign Service Institute's experience.

The speaker introduces the topic of language learning time estimates and references the US Foreign Service Institute's experience.

  • The speaker announces the topic of discussion: the time it takes to learn a language.
  • He mentions he frequently gets asked this question and will base the discussion on the FSI's list.
  • The FSI has over 75 years of experience teaching languages to its personnel.

Chapter 2

Outline of Main Points

0:22 - 36 sec

The speaker outlines the main points he will cover, including the FSI's list, language learning levels, time spent, and factors affecting language difficulty.

The speaker outlines the main points he will cover, including the FSI's list, language learning levels, time spent, and factors affecting language difficulty.

  • He plans to review the FSI's list of languages categorized by difficulty.
  • The discussion will include the level of proficiency the FSI claims learners can achieve.
  • He will explore how time is spent in learning activities and what leads to proficiency according to the FSI.
  • Factors within languages that affect ease or difficulty of learning will be examined.
  • External factors that influence language learning difficulty will also be discussed.

Chapter 3

FSI's Language Categories by Difficulty

1:03 - 1 min, 32 sec

The speaker reviews the FSI's language categories by difficulty, raising questions about the assigned timeframes and pronunciation challenges.

The speaker reviews the FSI's language categories by difficulty, raising questions about the assigned timeframes and pronunciation challenges.

  • Category one languages are considered the easiest for English speakers, including European languages with a study time of 24-30 weeks.
  • The speaker questions Danish's placement in the same category as Swedish, citing Danish's difficult pronunciation and writing system.
  • He finds the inclusion of Romanian reasonable and notes the varying time frames for learning different languages.

Chapter 4

Personal Language Learning Experiences

2:37 - 55 sec

The speaker shares his personal experiences with languages from various FSI categories, highlighting the challenges of pronunciation and writing systems.

The speaker shares his personal experiences with languages from various FSI categories, highlighting the challenges of pronunciation and writing systems.

  • He has learned languages from categories one and two and discusses his experiences with them.
  • The speaker has not learned category three languages but has heard they are easy due to a transparent writing system.
  • He is skeptical of the FSI's timeframe for achieving proficiency in category four languages due to their different writing systems.

Chapter 5

Learning the Most Difficult Languages

3:39 - 1 min, 0 sec

The speaker addresses the FSI's category five languages, which include languages with different writing systems and cultural factors affecting learning.

The speaker addresses the FSI's category five languages, which include languages with different writing systems and cultural factors affecting learning.

  • Category five languages are estimated to take around 88 weeks to learn and include Arabic, Cantonese, Mandarin, Japanese, and Korean.
  • He shares his experience learning Mandarin in nine to ten months and his struggles with Korean and Arabic.
  • The speaker emphasizes the importance of motivation and the role of interesting content in learning a difficult language.

Chapter 6

Realistic Expectations for Language Proficiency Levels

4:50 - 39 sec

The speaker expresses skepticism about achieving B2 proficiency in the FSI's suggested timeframes and discusses the concept of language gestation.

The speaker expresses skepticism about achieving B2 proficiency in the FSI's suggested timeframes and discusses the concept of language gestation.

  • The speaker doubts that learners can reach B2-C1 level within 5-7 months as suggested by the FSI.
  • He describes B2 as a high degree of fluency and believes that languages need time to gestate, allowing for better retention and understanding over time.
  • Even after the study period ends, languages continue to develop in the learner's mind.

Chapter 7

Time Spent in Instruction and Self-Study

6:05 - 59 sec

The speaker discusses how time is allocated during language instruction at the FSI and the importance of self-study.

The speaker discusses how time is allocated during language instruction at the FSI and the importance of self-study.

  • The FSI program includes five hours of group instruction daily, complemented by audio and other materials for self-study.
  • The speaker finds that five hours of daily instruction is excessive and tiring, suggesting that three hours is more ideal.
  • He emphasizes the need for personal exploration of the language and the increased availability of language content for self-study.

Chapter 8

Factors Affecting Language Learning Difficulty

8:38 - 1 min, 32 sec

The speaker analyzes various factors that make some languages more difficult to learn than others, including writing systems and vocabulary.

The speaker analyzes various factors that make some languages more difficult to learn than others, including writing systems and vocabulary.

  • Writing system familiarity, vocabulary similarity, and transparency of writing systems are key factors influencing language difficulty.
  • Structural patterns and case endings in languages such as German or Slavic languages present challenges.
  • The speaker shares his struggles with adapting to different writing systems and the time it takes for the brain to adjust.

Chapter 9

External Factors and Personal Motivation

11:15 - 1 min, 1 sec

The speaker examines external factors, including learner motivation and content availability, that impact the ease of learning a language.

The speaker examines external factors, including learner motivation and content availability, that impact the ease of learning a language.

  • High motivation significantly eases the learning process for any language.
  • Availability of interesting content keeps learners engaged and motivated.
  • Differences in dialects, such as various forms of Arabic, can increase learning difficulty.

Chapter 10

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

12:20 - 53 sec

The speaker concludes with thoughts on language learning duration, enjoyment, and the goal of reaching a solid foundational level.

The speaker concludes with thoughts on language learning duration, enjoyment, and the goal of reaching a solid foundational level.

  • He emphasizes the importance of enjoying the language learning process and being realistic about timeframes.
  • The goal should be to reach a solid foundational level, a springboard for future improvement.
  • The speaker suggests that reaching a B2 level in a few months is unlikely but that a good start in any language is possible.

More Steve Kaufmann - lingosteve summaries

Why learning languages in 2024 is just NOT worth it

Why learning languages in 2024 is just NOT worth it

Steve Kaufmann - lingosteve

Steve Kaufmann - lingosteve

A YouTuber with over a million followers shares a moment of doubt about the value of learning languages.

Don't try to memorize vocabulary in a new language

Don't try to memorize vocabulary in a new language

Steve Kaufmann - lingosteve

Steve Kaufmann - lingosteve

Steve Kaufmann discusses why traditional methods of memorizing vocabulary are not effective and offers insights into more efficient language learning techniques.

I’ve learned 20 languages: what keeps me going?

I’ve learned 20 languages: what keeps me going?

Steve Kaufmann - lingosteve

Steve Kaufmann - lingosteve

A detailed journey through language connections and personal acquisition experiences.