I'm back in a diesel after 4yrs running both EV & PHEV. What needs to change to get me to go back?

Harry's garage

Harry's garage

28 min, 46 sec

The video discusses the current state of the automotive market, reasons behind the decline in electric vehicle (EV) secondhand prices, and the presenter's personal decision to buy a diesel car over an EV.

Summary

  • The presenter reflects on the shift in the automotive market and his own decision to purchase a diesel Range Rover Sport as a family car.
  • He discusses the high depreciation rates of electric vehicles, the unexpected drop in secondhand EV prices, and the frustration of consumers with EVs.
  • An analysis of the EV market reveals that high costs, unpredictable depreciation, and concerns over battery degradation are influencing buyer decisions.
  • The presenter argues for the need for efficiency standards in EV production and better consumer information on battery health.
  • He also calls for a reality check on the impact of EVs on global CO2 emissions, suggesting that EVs alone will not dramatically alter global warming.

Chapter 1

Introduction to the Automotive Market Discussion

0:00 - 54 sec

The presenter introduces the topic of the current automotive market situation and his recent purchase of a diesel car.

The presenter introduces the topic of the current automotive market situation and his recent purchase of a diesel car.

  • The presenter explains his intention to deep dive into the automotive market and his personal car purchase decision.
  • He mentions a previous video where he considered EVs and PHEVs, reflecting on his past experience with an electric Jaguar I-Pace.
  • The decision to buy a diesel Range Rover Sport is highlighted as the focus of the discussion.

Chapter 2

Evaluating the EV Market and Secondhand Prices

0:53 - 48 sec

The presenter examines the current state of the EV market, focusing on secondhand prices and consumer frustration.

The presenter examines the current state of the EV market, focusing on secondhand prices and consumer frustration.

  • Discussion on the depreciation of EVs and the presenter's frustration with this aspect.
  • The video addresses the uncertainty in the EV market and the need for changes in direction.
  • The presenter references Akio Toyoda's prediction that pure electric vehicles will only account for 30% of the global market.

Chapter 3

Financial Considerations in Vehicle Selection

1:41 - 1 min, 28 sec

The presenter discusses the financial factors that influenced his choice of a diesel car over an EV or PHEV.

The presenter discusses the financial factors that influenced his choice of a diesel car over an EV or PHEV.

  • Comparison of monthly payments for different models of Range Rover highlights the cost savings of diesel over PHEVs.
  • The presenter expresses his preference for the design of the Range Rover Sport and considers it a practical choice for his needs.
  • He shares his decision process and how cost-effectiveness played a major role in selecting a diesel car.

Chapter 4

Automotive Market Shifts and Buyer Behavior

3:09 - 36 sec

An overview of changes in the automotive market, with a focus on the decline in private car purchases and the rise of fleet buyers.

An overview of changes in the automotive market, with a focus on the decline in private car purchases and the rise of fleet buyers.

  • The presenter talks about new car sales data from the UK and the noticeable shift in the market composition.
  • Discussion on the reluctance of private buyers to invest in cars, especially EVs, and the factors contributing to this trend.
  • The video touches upon the presenter's personal views on EVs, their fit for his family's needs, and his early adoption of green technologies.

Chapter 5

Industry Changes and Government Incentives

3:45 - 1 min, 34 sec

Exploration of the automotive industry's evolution, driven by regulations and government incentives for EV adoption.

Exploration of the automotive industry's evolution, driven by regulations and government incentives for EV adoption.

  • The presenter reflects on the impact of Euro 7 regulations and the rise of Tesla on the automotive industry's direction.
  • He criticizes government incentives that favor businesses buying expensive electric cars for tax savings, which don't align with private buyer preferences.
  • The discussion includes the consequences of these incentives on car pricing, insurance costs, and the type of EVs being produced.

Chapter 6

Car Insurance and the Impact of EV Features

5:18 - 2 min, 33 sec

The presenter considers the insurance industry's perspective on EVs and the impact of car features on insurance costs.

The presenter considers the insurance industry's perspective on EVs and the impact of car features on insurance costs.

  • Insight into the insurance industry's concerns with electric cars, including repair times and the high power of some models.
  • The presenter shares discussions with insurance companies and the specific challenges they face with high-performance EVs.
  • He also provides information on the insurance situation for Range Rover models, distinguishing between previous and current generations.

Chapter 7

Battery Degradation in EVs

7:51 - 3 min, 27 sec

The presenter delves into the issue of battery degradation in electric vehicles and its impact on value and performance.

The presenter delves into the issue of battery degradation in electric vehicles and its impact on value and performance.

  • The video highlights the lack of information on battery health as a major concern for EV owners and the used car market.
  • A discussion of various EVs and their battery degradation rates, referencing studies from Norway, is presented.
  • The presenter advocates for better transparency in battery health data to aid consumers and the automotive industry.

Chapter 8

Charging Network and Cost Concerns

11:18 - 3 min, 39 sec

Discussion on the practical challenges of charging EVs outside the home and the associated costs.

Discussion on the practical challenges of charging EVs outside the home and the associated costs.

  • The presenter discusses the charging network's limitations and the inconvenience of relying on external chargers.
  • He emphasizes the significant cost difference between home charging and public charging stations.
  • The video addresses the need for EVs to have greater range to compensate for the time required to recharge.

Chapter 9

Cold Weather Impact on EV Range

14:56 - 3 min, 11 sec

The presenter highlights how cold weather significantly reduces the range of electric vehicles, causing frustration for users.

The presenter highlights how cold weather significantly reduces the range of electric vehicles, causing frustration for users.

  • Personal experiences with reduced EV range during winter are shared.
  • A car magazine's real-world test of EV range in cold conditions is discussed, reflecting common issues faced by EV owners.
  • The need for improved cold weather performance in EVs is emphasized as a factor hindering widespread adoption.

Chapter 10

Recommendations for the EV Revolution

18:07 - 10 min, 37 sec

The presenter offers recommendations for advancing the EV revolution, addressing efficiency, battery health, and CO2 reduction strategies.

The presenter offers recommendations for advancing the EV revolution, addressing efficiency, battery health, and CO2 reduction strategies.

  • The video proposes the introduction of efficiency scales for EV production and better consumer access to battery health information.
  • A reality check on the impact of EVs on global CO2 emissions is suggested, along with exploring additional methods for CO2 reduction.
  • The presenter's skepticism about the readiness of the EV market for mass adoption is expressed, citing technological advancements and the need for more practical solutions.