Japan VS Foreign Tourists: A Worsening Situation
Abroad in Japan
10 min, 43 sec
The video discusses the impact of foreign tourists' misbehavior in Japan, including a ban in Kyoto and other incidents across the country, and the broader implications for cultural preservation amid mass tourism.
Summary
- The speaker reminisces about his visit to Kyoto's Gion district, noting its unchanged historical beauty and expressing shock over a subsequent ban on foreign tourists due to misbehavior toward geisha.
- He describes incidents of disrespectful tourist behavior, such as touching geisha, taking unauthorized photos, and defacing cultural sites which led to the ban and other strict measures.
- The video highlights the negative implications of mass tourism for Japan's cultural heritage and raises questions about the balance between openness and preservation.
- Examples of misbehavior include carving names into bamboo trees, damaging shrines by inserting coins, and the negative impact on local temples.
- The speaker suggests that while some tourist-caused problems are unintended, common sense and respect for local customs and rules are essential for preserving cultural sites.
Chapter 1
The speaker describes the historical allure of Kyoto's Gion district and his shock at the city's decision to ban foreign tourists due to disrespectful behavior towards geisha.
- Kyoto's Gion district is famed for its historical significance, traditional wooden houses, and geisha sightings.
- Due to misbehavior by foreign tourists, such as taking unauthorized photos and touching geisha, Kyoto announced a ban on foreign tourists in the area the speaker had visited.
- The ban's announcement led the speaker to initially worry about his own conduct but he soon realized the broader issue with tourist behavior.
Chapter 2
The speaker discusses the disrespectful interactions between foreign tourists and geisha, and jokes about unconventional solutions to deter such behavior.
- Foreign tourists have treated geisha inappropriately, like theme park characters, leading to increased fines and ultimately the tourist ban.
- The speaker humorously suggests that dressing Yakuza members as geisha might deter tourists from disrespectful actions.
- He expresses his personal thoughts on the situation, including the surprise at his own indirect involvement.
Chapter 3
The speaker expands on the problems caused by foreign tourists across Japan, including defacing temples and other publicized incidents involving influencers.
- The issues with tourists in Kyoto are not isolated, as similar disrespectful behaviors have been reported throughout Japan.
- Some foreign influencers have exacerbated the situation by publicly engaging in disrespectful acts, such as defacing temples.
- The speaker hopes that his viewers would not partake in such behaviors and stresses that it's not just about rules, but about being a decent human being.
Chapter 4
The speaker addresses the anxieties tourists have about cultural faux pas in Japan, emphasizing that respect and common sense are key.
- Many potential visitors to Japan worry about violating cultural norms, but the speaker reassures that honest mistakes are generally forgiven.
- He highlights that common sense behaviors, such as not defiling cultural sites, are more important than minor etiquette errors.
- The speaker uses humor to condemn the act of carving names into historic sites, suggesting that it's not just foolish but also disrespectful.
Chapter 5
The speaker recounts instances where tourists vandalized important cultural sites, highlighting the severity of their actions and the penalties they face.
- Tourists have carved their names into bamboo trees in Kyoto and even into ancient temples, causing significant damage.
- In one case, a Canadian teenager admitted to defacing a temple and faced the possibility of heavy fines or imprisonment.
- The speaker sarcastically comments on a similar incident in Rome, criticizing the lack of awareness and respect for historic monuments.
Chapter 6
The speaker discusses how even well-meaning tourists can inadvertently cause harm to cultural sites.
- Tourists have unintentionally damaged shrines by inserting coins for good luck, leading to the necessity of costly renovations.
- The speaker humorously imagines the amount of money collected from the coins and how it could contribute to restoration efforts.
- He mentions that these types of incidents are not as widely known but still have a significant impact on cultural preservation.
Chapter 7
The speaker points out various instances of cultural misunderstandings and insensitivity towards Japanese customs by foreign tourists.
- A convenience store sign aimed at foreign customers was written in Japanese, indicating a lack of understanding by the store about their target audience.
- A Hokkaido government booklet intended for Chinese tourists was criticized for being condescending and featured an inappropriate illustration.
- These examples show that not all negative interactions are due to malice; some are born out of ignorance or poor communication.
Chapter 8
The speaker discusses the tangible consequences of tourist misbehavior, such as temples refusing entry to non-Japanese visitors.
- The Nanzoin Temple in Fukuoka went as far as turning away non-Japanese tourist groups after disrespectful behavior, including splashing in a sacred waterfall.
- The speaker expresses his personal dismay at the thought of people disrespecting such a historically significant site.
- He understands the temple's frustration and agrees with the need for protective measures to preserve the integrity of the site.
Chapter 9
The speaker reflects on the impact of mass tourism on Japan's cultural heritage and the challenges of balancing accessibility with preservation.
- Mass tourism is a recent phenomenon in Japan, with visitor numbers increasing from around 6 million to a predicted 33 million in 20 years.
- There are concerns that unchecked tourism could harm the country's traditional customs and the unique experience of visiting Japan.
- The speaker shares his concerns over the potential for more areas to become restricted and the implications for Japan's cultural identity.
Chapter 10
The speaker concludes the video by asking for viewers' opinions on the tourist ban in Kyoto and signs off with a jest about engaging in graffiti.
- The speaker invites viewers to share their thoughts on whether banning tourists is an excessive or necessary measure for preserving Kyoto's identity.
- He thanks viewers for watching and jokes about carving a donkey into a wall as a newfound thrill, highlighting his humorous approach to the topic.
- The video ends with a musical outro.
More Abroad in Japan summaries
What Life in Fukushima's Nuclear Exclusion Zone is Like
Abroad in Japan
The video documents a return to the Fukushima exclusion zone, reflecting on the progress and challenges of recovery since the 2011 disaster.
This Town in Japan Has a Big Problem
Abroad in Japan
A detailed journey through Akita Prefecture featuring various attractions, challenges, and experiences.
12 Things NO-ONE Tells You About Japan | Feat. @CDawgVA
Abroad in Japan
A detailed conversation about lesser-known aspects of life in Japan, covering topics from language nuances to cultural behaviors.