Misconceptions About Popular Songs & Lyrics
Mental Floss
9 min, 44 sec
A detailed exploration of widely held yet incorrect beliefs about the meanings and lyrics of various popular songs.
Summary
- James Blunt's 'You're Beautiful' is not a romantic song but a creepy story from a stalker's perspective.
- 'Smells Like Teen Spirit' by Nirvana contains seemingly nonsensical lyrics with no underlying revolutionary message.
- The Baha Men's 'Who Let The Dogs Out' actually carries a feminist message, contrary to popular belief.
- Phil Collins' 'In the Air Tonight' is not about witnessing a drowning but was inspired by his divorce.
- 'Born in the USA' by Bruce Springsteen is a critical look at America, not a patriotic anthem.
Chapter 1
James Blunt's 'You're Beautiful' is not the romantic song many people think it is.
- The song was written from the perspective of someone high on the subway, leering at another man's girlfriend.
- Blunt envisioned the story ending with the stalker character committing suicide.
- This darker subtext is showcased in the music video where the protagonist jumps off a cliff.
Chapter 2
Nirvana's 'Smells Like Teen Spirit' is often misunderstood, with no clear revolutionary message in its lyrics.
- Listeners often misheard the lyrics, with the title referencing a deodorant brand and not featured in the song.
- Kurt Cobain stated the lyrics are nonsensical, denying a deeper meaning despite its reputation as a Gen X anthem.
- The song includes random poetry and lyrics, often written last minute by Cobain.
Chapter 3
Contrary to popular belief, 'Who Let The Dogs Out' by the Baha Men has a feminist message.
- The term 'dogs' is not meant as an insult to women but refers to misbehaving men at a party.
- The original song was a response to catcalling, with women calling out the harassers.
- The Baha Men's music video can be interpreted to show men transforming into dogs and back.
Chapter 4
Jimi Hendrix's 'Purple Haze' lyrics are commonly misheard, but do not involve kissing a man.
- Many believed Hendrix sang 'Excuse me while I kiss this guy' rather than 'kiss the sky'.
- Hendrix found the misunderstanding amusing and would intentionally sing the wrong lyrics live.
- The misinterpretation didn't bother him, and it became a part of his performances.
Chapter 5
Bruce Springsteen's 'Born in the USA' is often mistaken for a patriotic song but is critical of America.
- The song tells the story of a Vietnam War veteran's struggles upon returning home.
- Its catchy chorus has led to misinterpretation and misuse by politicians without Springsteen's approval.
Chapter 6
Phil Collins' 'In the Air Tonight' is not about witnessing a drowning, but was inspired by personal turmoil.
- An urban legend suggests the song recounts Collins witnessing a drowning and addressing the non-rescuer.
- Collins actually wrote the song during his divorce and improvised the lyrics.
Chapter 7
'99 Luftballons' by Nena is not a light-hearted song but a commentary on the Cold War.
- The song imagines balloons causing a nuclear war after being mistaken for an attack.
- The English version, '99 Red Balloons', maintains the serious message against a poppy synth beat.
Chapter 8
Manford Man's Earth Band's 'Blinded By the Light' contains a frequently misheard lyric involving a 'deuce'.
- Listeners often mishear 'wrapped up like a deuce' as a reference to a feminine hygiene product.
- The original Bruce Springsteen lyric was 'cut loose like a deuce', while the cover version altered it.
- The band claims it was a technical issue with recording that led to the confusion.
Chapter 9
R.E.M.'s 'The One I Love' is mistakenly considered a love song but actually depicts an abusive relationship.
- Guitarist Peter Buck described it as 'savagely anti-love'.
- Michael Stipe, the lead singer, was hesitant to record it due to its violent nature.
- The song's true meaning is often overlooked, leading to its inappropriate use in romantic settings.
More Mental Floss summaries
11 Amazing Historical Coincidences
Mental Floss
A video detailing a series of strange and interesting historical coincidences.
Misconceptions About the Great Depression
Mental Floss
A deep dive into common misconceptions about the Great Depression, including economic causes, the lives of celebrities, and the reality of food during that era.