NYC is Building Anti-Homeless Streets…

Cash Jordan

Cash Jordan

14 min, 27 sec

The video explores various examples of hostile architecture in New York City, discussing how urban design can be used to deter homeless individuals and others from using public spaces.

Summary

  • Hostile architecture includes armrests on benches, spikes, and uneven surfaces to prevent the homeless from sleeping in public areas.
  • Critics argue that these measures are cruel and target the most needy, without addressing the root cause of homelessness.
  • Examples of hostile architecture are found in subway stations, where benches are removed or redesigned to discourage loitering.
  • New train stations and parks are also designed with minimal seating or uncomfortable surfaces to discourage prolonged use.
  • The video questions the ethical implications of designing public spaces that lower the standard of living for everyone.

Chapter 1

Introduction to Hostile Architecture

0:00 - 1 min, 49 sec

The video begins by explaining the concept of hostile architecture and showing examples in New York City.

The video begins by explaining the concept of hostile architecture and showing examples in New York City.

  • Hostile architecture is designed to prevent homeless people from sleeping in public spaces.
  • The video shows metal coverings on subway vents and uneven surfaces on seating to deter lying down.

Chapter 2

Subway Station Hostile Design

1:50 - 2 min, 12 sec

The video highlights how subway stations implement hostile architecture, focusing on the 23rd Street and 6th Avenue stop.

The video highlights how subway stations implement hostile architecture, focusing on the 23rd Street and 6th Avenue stop.

  • Benches were removed from the subway station, causing public outrage, especially as it affected the elderly and pregnant women.
  • After criticism, some benches were reinstalled but with armrests to prevent lying down.

Chapter 3

Moynihan Train Hall's Lack of Seating

4:02 - 3 min, 13 sec

The video critiques the Moynihan Train Hall for its lack of seating, suggesting it may be a form of hostile architecture.

The video critiques the Moynihan Train Hall for its lack of seating, suggesting it may be a form of hostile architecture.

  • Despite its impressive design and amenities, Moynihan Train Hall has no public seating areas.
  • The absence of benches is seen as an intentional design to keep people from staying too long.

Chapter 4

Penn Station and Hostile Designs

7:14 - 2 min, 18 sec

The video compares the old Penn Station with the new design and discusses the impact of hostile architecture on loitering and small businesses.

The video compares the old Penn Station with the new design and discusses the impact of hostile architecture on loitering and small businesses.

  • The new Penn Station design has no public seating, similar to Moynihan Train Hall.
  • The city removed seatbacks from benches in an effort to reduce loitering and assist businesses.

Chapter 5

High Line Park's Uncomfortable Seating

9:32 - 2 min, 35 sec

The video explores the High Line Park, noting its narrow and uncomfortable seating installations that discourage prolonged use.

The video explores the High Line Park, noting its narrow and uncomfortable seating installations that discourage prolonged use.

  • The High Line Park has seating designed to move traffic and prevent large gatherings.
  • Some seating areas in the park are more comfortable, but others are awkward and discourage staying long.

Chapter 6

Zuccotti Park's Hostile Design

12:07 - 2 min, 16 sec

The video concludes with a visit to Zuccotti Park, highlighting its use of hostile architecture during the Occupy Wall Street movement.

The video concludes with a visit to Zuccotti Park, highlighting its use of hostile architecture during the Occupy Wall Street movement.

  • Zuccotti Park features cold granite with high ridges and uncomfortable tables, designed to deter crowds.
  • The Occupy Wall Street protesters managed to camp in the park despite its unfriendly design.

More Cash Jordan summaries

NYC’s Drinking Water is Now Toxic… Why?

NYC’s Drinking Water is Now Toxic… Why?

Cash Jordan

Cash Jordan

A detailed examination of New York City's water quality, addressing concerns about pollution, lead content, and the water treatment process.