Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05]
Not Just Bikes
18 min, 14 sec
The video explains the concept of 'stroads' and contrasts them with streets and roads, outlining their dangers, expenses, and lack of effectiveness.
Summary
- Stroads, a street-road hybrid, are dangerous, expensive, and ineffective.
- The video distinguishes between a road (high-speed connection) and a street (a complex environment for city life).
- Stroads are criticized for being unfriendly to pedestrians and cyclists, causing traffic congestion, and being financially unproductive.
- Alternatives such as converting stroads to proper roads or streets are suggested, with examples from the Netherlands' approach to urban design.
Chapter 1
The video introduces the concept of stroads and the issues associated with them.
- Stroads, prevalent in the U.S and Canada, are a street-road hybrid that are dangerous, expensive, and ineffective.
- They lack infrastructure for safe pedestrian and cyclist use and are difficult to cross without a vehicle.
- Strong Towns coined the term to highlight their problematic nature.
Chapter 2
The video explains the differences between roads and streets.
- A road is a high-speed connection between two places with safety features to accommodate fast-moving vehicles.
- A street is a complex city environment designed for life activities, low speeds, and human-scale interactions.
- Both roads and streets are important and serve different purposes.
Chapter 3
The video discusses how stroads fail to fulfill the functions of either roads or streets.
- Stroads mix high-speed lanes with numerous points of conflict, such as driveways and side streets, creating dangerous situations.
- They are designed in a way that is hostile to non-motorized users, causing them to be underused and overlooked.
- Stroads lead to traffic congestion due to frequent stopping at traffic signals and high-speed lane designs that encourage speeding.
Chapter 4
The video outlines the safety concerns and financial burdens of stroads.
- Stroads contribute to the high number of fatal crashes within cities, especially for pedestrians and cyclists.
- The wide lanes and extensive infrastructure of stroads are costly to build and maintain.
- They generate low tax revenue per acre due to their design, which includes large parking lots and low-density development.
Chapter 5
The video suggests alternatives to stroads by turning them into roads or streets.
- Turning a stroad into a road involves limiting access, removing bicycle gutters, and separating pedestrian and cyclist paths from traffic.
- Converting a stroad into a street requires narrowing lanes, moving parking, and encouraging human-scale development.
Chapter 6
The video showcases the Dutch approach to urban design, which avoids stroads.
- The Netherlands has implemented a system with three types of infrastructure: highways, distributor roads, and neighborhood access streets.
- This design philosophy effectively separates high-speed traffic from local destinations to improve safety and efficiency.
Chapter 7
The video details how the Netherlands transitioned to safer and more productive roads and streets.
- The Dutch redesigned their streets and roads over 30 years, classifying them as highways (stromvich), distributor roads, or neighborhood access streets (erftoegangswegen).
- This classification system has led to a significant decrease in through traffic on streets, improving safety and livability.
Chapter 8
The video concludes with a call to action for the U.S. and Canada to follow the Dutch model.
- Stroads should be redesigned into either productive streets or efficient roads to improve safety and city finances.
- This could result in fewer traffic deaths, more viable alternatives to driving, less traffic, and more financially productive cities.
More Not Just Bikes summaries
Germany's "Green" City (with more bikes than cars!)
Not Just Bikes
The video explores Freiburg, a city in Germany's Black Forest known for its sustainable urban development. It highlights the city's bicycle and tram infrastructure, pedestrian-friendly streets, sustainable city planning, and successful environmental activism.
Would You Fall for It? [ST08]
Not Just Bikes
A detailed critique of General Motors' 1954 film promoting increased road funding, which led to issues in American urban development.
I Visited the Best* City in North America
Not Just Bikes
A comprehensive review of Montreal's urban landscape, exploring its improvements, public transit, cycling infrastructure, and some areas for improvement.