The individual can only be insecure | J. Krishnamurti

The video discusses the false sense of security found in individualism and separation, and the consequences in personal relationships and society.

Summary

  • The speakers examine the notion that solitude and isolation offer no true security.
  • The discussion highlights the insecurities inherent in individualism and the pretense of independence.
  • A realization that the self is not separate from the world brings a sense of true security.
  • Material security is questioned in the face of global interdependence and societal divisions.
  • The struggle of communicating the value of non-separation in a world clinging to individualism is explored.

Chapter 1

The Insecurity of Solitude

0:00 - 29 sec

The speakers discuss solitude and isolation, pointing out their inherent insecurity.

The speakers discuss solitude and isolation, pointing out their inherent insecurity.

  • Solitude is presented as inherently insecure, without any possibility of security.
  • Isolation is deemed insecure for an individual, as there is no true safety or certainty in it.

Chapter 2

Understanding Dependence and Insecurity

0:35 - 55 sec

David Bohm and the speaker discuss the pretense of independence and the resulting insecurities.

David Bohm and the speaker discuss the pretense of independence and the resulting insecurities.

  • David Bohm argues that individuals, while dependent on everyone, often pretend they are not, leading to insecurity.
  • Acknowledging the lack of individual security can lead to a sense of greater security through non-separation.

Chapter 3

Material Security and National Identity

1:47 - 52 sec

The concept of material security is questioned, and the insecurity stemming from national identity is addressed.

The concept of material security is questioned, and the insecurity stemming from national identity is addressed.

  • Material security, including the need for money and shelter, is becoming increasingly difficult to ensure.
  • Identifying with a nation, such as being British, and the opposition to others, breeds more insecurity.

Chapter 4

The Challenge of Recognizing Shared Insecurity

2:41 - 56 sec

The speakers explore the difficulty of convincing others of the shared insecurity caused by individualism.

The speakers explore the difficulty of convincing others of the shared insecurity caused by individualism.

  • Even if some individuals recognize the insecurity of isolation, they may still be threatened by those who do not see it.
  • The world tends to believe security lies in isolation, leading to attacks and danger for those who think differently.

Chapter 5

The Risk of Challenging Individualism

3:48 - 1 min, 3 sec

The risk of opposing individualism and advocating for non-separation in society is discussed.

The risk of opposing individualism and advocating for non-separation in society is discussed.

  • Opposing individualism can be dangerous, as it challenges societal norms and can result in either being idolized or ostracized.
  • Trying to convey the message of non-separation to those deeply entrenched in individualism is a daunting task.

Chapter 6

The Impact of Shared Understanding

4:59 - 1 min, 3 sec

The speakers consider the impact of having a collective understanding of the dangers of isolation.

The speakers consider the impact of having a collective understanding of the dangers of isolation.

  • If a group collectively understands the insecurity of isolation, it could lead to significant change.
  • However, there is a lack of clarity on what that change would entail in practical terms.

Chapter 7

Confronting the World's Division

6:37 - 1 min, 10 sec

The speakers address the difficulty of communicating the perils of isolation to politicians and religious leaders.

The speakers address the difficulty of communicating the perils of isolation to politicians and religious leaders.

  • Politicians and religious leaders, representing divided groups, are likely to reject the idea of non-separation.
  • The challenge is to find out what to do in a world that doesn't listen and is resistant to change.

Chapter 8

The Dilemma of Non-Listening Societies

8:03 - 27 sec

The speakers discuss the fortunate indifference of those in power to conversations about individualism and security.

The speakers discuss the fortunate indifference of those in power to conversations about individualism and security.

  • Authorities like politicians, police, and immigration officials are often too enclosed in their views to consider alternative perspectives.
  • This closed-mindedness somewhat fortuitously prevents them from acting against those who challenge the status quo.

Chapter 9

Relationship Dynamics in the Face of Change

9:10 - 3 min, 0 sec

The implications of one partner losing individuality and the other not, within a relationship, are explored.

The implications of one partner losing individuality and the other not, within a relationship, are explored.

  • When one partner in a relationship loses their sense of individuality and the other does not, it creates a dilemma of action and responsibility.
  • Continued discussion and love may not bridge the gap if one partner remains committed to individualism.

Chapter 10

The Inevitability of Separation

12:21 - 1 min, 21 sec

The inevitability of separation when one partner changes and the other does not is discussed.

The inevitability of separation when one partner changes and the other does not is discussed.

  • If one person in a relationship changes their views on individuality and the other remains entrenched, separation may be inevitable.
  • The difficulty of changing another person's mind is acknowledged, emphasizing personal choice and responsibility.

Chapter 11

Love in the Face of Disunity

14:17 - 45 sec

The role of love in navigating a relationship where one person has changed and the other has not is considered.

The role of love in navigating a relationship where one person has changed and the other has not is considered.

  • Even if one person has love in their heart, it may not be enough to maintain a relationship with someone who does not want to change.
  • The speakers deliberate on what action to take when love and communication fail to resolve differences.

Chapter 12

The Unwillingness to Change

15:30 - 1 min, 19 sec

The speakers debate the unwillingness to change, both in themselves and in others.

The speakers debate the unwillingness to change, both in themselves and in others.

  • Individuals may resist changing their individualistic mindset, and the question arises of what to do in such situations.
  • The speakers question whether they themselves are prepared to change, highlighting the importance of self-awareness.

More J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel summaries

J. Krishnamurti - Brockwood Park 1980 - Small Group Discussion - Thought is the beginning of desire

J. Krishnamurti - Brockwood Park 1980 - Small Group Discussion - Thought is the beginning of desire

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

An in-depth dialogue about the intricacies of the mind, the process of thought, and the nature of desire and pleasure.

Society has helped us to have no capacity | J. Krishnamurti

Society has helped us to have no capacity | J. Krishnamurti

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

The speaker discusses the concept of conditioned incapacity and the journey towards self-reliance and intelligence.

Meditation and control | J. Krishnamurti

Meditation and control | J. Krishnamurti

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

A detailed exploration of what meditation truly entails, emphasizing the rejection of systematic practices and the cultivation of awareness, concentration, and attention.

Audio | J. Krishnamurti - London 1966 Interview - Dying is living and living is dying

Audio | J. Krishnamurti - London 1966 Interview - Dying is living and living is dying

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

Francis Watson interviews philosopher and educator Jiddu Krishnamurti, exploring his life, beliefs, and teachings.

What is freedom? | J. Krishnamurti

What is freedom? | J. Krishnamurti

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

J. Krishnamurti - Official Channel

The speaker discusses the philosophical and practical aspects of freedom, questioning its true nature and how it manifests in our lives.