The Only Unbreakable Law
Molly Rocket
53 min, 25 sec
A detailed analysis of how organizational structures influence software architecture, drawing from Melvin Conway's 1968 paper.
Summary
- Melvin Conway's 1968 paper posits that organizations are constrained in designing systems which mirror their communication structures.
- Conway's Law suggests that the optimal design a team can achieve will mirror the team's organizational chart.
- Software longevity and practices like OOP and microservices introduce additional layers of 'organizational' constraints within the code itself.
- Modern software development often violates the principle of 'lean and flexible' due to complex interdependencies introduced by organizational and historical factors.
Chapter 1
An introduction to the concept of Conway's Law and its implications on software architecture over a programmer's career.
- The speaker introduces the concept of how advice can quickly become outdated in the field of programming.
- The focus is on finding any enduring principles within software architecture that would stand the test of time.
- Conway's Law is presented as a potential candidate for an unbreakable law within software architecture.
Chapter 2
An explanation of what constitutes a law in other domains, using physics as an example to set the stage for software laws.
- The speaker explains the nature of laws in physics, using Newton's law of gravitation as a classic example.
- Newton's law demonstrates how laws can endure for centuries, even when they are eventually refined by new theories like Einstein's theory of relativity.
- The longevity and adaptability of laws in physics are offered as a benchmark for what might be considered a law in software.
Chapter 3
A discussion on the existence of laws in software, with examples of principles that approximate immutable truths.
- The speaker questions whether there are any true laws in software, given its relative novelty compared to fields like physics.
- Amdahl's Law is discussed as a possible law in software, describing limitations in parallel computing.
- The talk addresses the distinction between 'laws' and 'principles' or 'rules of thumb' commonly found in software literature.
Chapter 4
The origin of Conway's Law from a 1968 paper and an in-depth exploration of its meaning.
- The origin of Conway's Law is traced back to a 1968 paper by Melvin Conway, highlighting its significance in the context of software architecture.
- The law suggests that organizations are predisposed to produce designs which are copies of their communication structures.
- Conway's Law is theorized to be a homomorphism between organizational charts and product architectures, implying that products reflect the structures that create them.
Chapter 5
The impact of Conway's Law on current software development practices, including the accumulation of historical organizational decisions.
- The speaker discusses how Conway's Law extends to include temporal organizational decisions, affecting the architecture of long-lived software.
- Examples from Windows operating system demonstrate how various organizational teams over time contribute to the current design and complexity.
- The talk identifies a trend where newer organizational decisions and structures are superimposed upon older ones, leading to compounded complexity.
More Molly Rocket summaries
The Thirty Million Line Problem
Molly Rocket
A detailed analysis of the issues with modern hardware and operating systems, and a proposal for a more manageable and efficient approach.
Where Does Bad Code Come From?
Molly Rocket
A detailed exploration of the origins of bad code and how programmers' mental models contribute to it.
Handmade Hero Day 001 - Setting Up the Windows Build
Molly Rocket
Detailing the process of setting up a development environment for Handmade Hero on Windows.