Too Big a Risk? Catastrophic Risks in Business and Investing
Aswath Damodaran
28 min, 50 sec
An in-depth exploration of how to handle catastrophe risks in business valuation and investment.
Summary
- Catastrophe risk is the risk of an extreme event that can threaten the very existence or significantly alter the trajectory of a company.
- Catastrophic risks can come from acts of God (natural disasters), man-made events, regulatory or tax law changes, and can be either insurable or uninsurable.
- Valuing catastrophe risk involves estimating the impact on cash flows, adjusting discount rates, or considering the likelihood of failure and its consequences on value.
- Investors and markets tend to underprice catastrophe risk when it's perceived to be a low-probability event, but may overreact when such risks become imminent.
- The response to catastrophic risks has implications for a wide range of stakeholders, from investors to homeowners, and can be challenging due to the human tendency to either deny or panic in the face of potential catastrophes.
Chapter 1
Introduction to the particular aspect of risk management focusing on catastrophe risk.
- The session opens by acknowledging the extensive discussion on risk and introduces the specific focus on catastrophe risk.
- Catastrophe risk is described as what businesses or investors face when encountering an event that can lead to their potential end.
Chapter 2
Real-world examples illustrate how companies face existential threats and how they are valued amidst such risks.
- The Icelandic spa, Blue Lagoon, faces a threat from a volcanic eruption, prompting questions about business valuation under existential threats.
- 23andMe experienced a data breach, which posed a significant risk to the company's existence due to compromised customer genetic information.
- Climate change is discussed as an existential crisis affecting sectors such as fossil fuels, impacting investor decisions and pricing.
Chapter 3
Different types of risks are categorized and methods to address them in valuation are explored.
- Risks are divided into categories such as economic, estimation, micro, macro, discrete, and continuous risks.
- Another categorization addresses incremental and catastrophic risks, with the latter being capable of significantly altering a company's trajectory or threatening its survival.
- Approaches to valuing catastrophic risks include examining insurability, sector-wide impact, market-wide impact, and the probabilities of occurrence.
Chapter 4
Valuation strategies for catastrophe risks that are insurable are discussed.
- When a risk is insurable, the cost of insurance can be incorporated into cash flows, affecting intrinsic value.
- The challenge arises when risks are not insurable or when insurance does not cover all potential losses.
Chapter 5
Approaches to valuing companies with uninsurable risks that do not threaten their existence.
- For uninsurable risks that do not lead to company failure, two valuations are done: one assuming the catastrophe does not occur and another accounting for the catastrophe.
- Probabilities are assigned to each scenario to determine the expected value.
Chapter 6
Valuation strategies for uninsurable risks that could cause a company's failure.
- For catastrophic risks that can lead to company failure, valuation involves estimating the going concern value and the failure value, then taking an expected value.
- Probabilities of failure and potential recovery values in the event of failure must be estimated.
Chapter 7
Valuation considerations for catastrophic risks that affect entire sectors or the market.
- Risks that affect entire sectors or the market may lead to adjustments in cost of equity, betas, and equity risk premiums.
- The approach is similar to valuing company-specific risks but with broader implications for discount rates.
Chapter 8
How markets price catastrophic risks and the typical human responses of denial and panic.
- Markets often underestimate the risk of catastrophes when they seem unlikely, but may overreact when they become more imminent.
- Human responses to catastrophe risk often fall into denial or panic, influencing market behavior.
Chapter 9
Fossil fuel companies' market performance in the context of climate change concerns is analyzed.
- Despite being targeted due to climate change concerns, fossil fuel companies have seen their market caps recover in recent years.
- The demand for energy from fossil fuels has not decreased significantly, and these companies continue to play a crucial role in the global energy supply.