Which AA Rechargeable Battery is Best after 1 Year? Let's find out! Eneloop, Duracell, Amazon, EBL

Project Farm

Project Farm

10 min, 33 sec

A detailed analysis of different brands of double-A rechargeable batteries after one year of use and one year of storage, including tests for capacity, self-discharge, and internal resistance.

Summary

  • Batteries were tested for their capacity after being used in solar lights for a year and compared to their rated capacities.
  • Batteries in storage for a year underwent a capacity test to evaluate self-discharge.
  • Internal resistance of both used and stored batteries was measured to assess battery health.
  • Japanese manufactured batteries generally outperformed Chinese manufactured batteries in capacity retention and internal resistance.

Chapter 1

Introduction and Background

0:00 - 29 sec

Introduction to the double-A rechargeable battery test and background of the experiment setup.

Introduction to the double-A rechargeable battery test and background of the experiment setup.

  • The video is a follow-up to an initial test of double-A rechargeable batteries from a year ago.
  • Batteries were placed in outdoor solar lights to charge and discharge over 300 times.
  • The test aims to determine the efficacy of the batteries after prolonged use.

Chapter 2

Testing Methodology

0:31 - 35 sec

Details of the testing procedure using the Powerex MH-C9000 Wizard1 charger.

Details of the testing procedure using the Powerex MH-C9000 Wizard1 charger.

  • The Powerex MH-C9000 Wizard1 charger is used for charging and discharging the batteries.
  • Each battery is charged, rested for an hour, discharged, rested again, and recharged, with the process taking about 24 hours.
  • Charging and discharging are done at 500 milliamps for each test.

Chapter 3

Initial Results of Used Batteries

1:06 - 1 min, 35 sec

Initial findings from the capacity test on the batteries used in solar lights for a year.

Initial findings from the capacity test on the batteries used in solar lights for a year.

  • The Rayovac battery retained 94% of its rated capacity, while the Thunderbolt held 95% and AmazonBasics black 99%.
  • Both Japanese-made AmazonBasics batteries outperformed the Chinese-made brands in the initial set of tests.
  • Energizer, EBL, Panasonic Eneloop, and IKEA Ladda batteries were also tested, with the Japanese-made batteries once again outperforming the Chinese-made ones.

Chapter 4

Final Results of Used Batteries

2:41 - 46 sec

Final capacity test results of the batteries after nearly a year of daily use.

Final capacity test results of the batteries after nearly a year of daily use.

  • Duracell outperformed all with 102% of its rated capacity, while Powerex showed 93% efficiency.
  • Price aside, Duracell, Powerex, EBL, and IKEA were top performers in terms of milliamp hours retention.
  • Brands were rated based on their own milliamp power capacity, with Duracell leading.

Chapter 5

42-Day Self-Discharge Test

3:26 - 1 min, 1 sec

Results of a 42-day self-discharge test on stored batteries.

Results of a 42-day self-discharge test on stored batteries.

  • IKEA Ladda and Duracell were tied for the least self-discharge, with Powerex closely behind.
  • Energizer, Eneloop, and AmazonBasics black had a very low self-discharge rate per day, while EBL had nearly double that rate.
  • After 42 days, high capacity batteries lost around 10% or more of their charge.

Chapter 6

One-Year Storage Self-Discharge Test

4:28 - 1 min, 56 sec

Testing and results of the batteries that have been sitting on a shelf for a year.

Testing and results of the batteries that have been sitting on a shelf for a year.

  • Rayovac, Harbor Freight, AmazonBasics black, and AmazonBasics silver were tested for their initial voltage after a year of storage.
  • The AmazonBasics black battery led with the highest initial voltage and milliamp capacity compared to the others tested.
  • The IKEA Ladda battery had the highest available milliamp hour capacity after one year of storage.

Chapter 7

Internal Resistance Measurement

6:24 - 2 min, 36 sec

Internal resistance measurement of both used and stored batteries.

Internal resistance measurement of both used and stored batteries.

  • Internal resistance is an indicator of the opposition to current flow within the battery.
  • The Opus BT-3400 charger was used to measure internal resistance.
  • Batteries used in solar lights for a year and those stored for a year showed different levels of internal resistance.

Chapter 8

Conclusion and Insights

9:01 - 57 sec

Final thoughts on the battery performance and the implications of the test results.

Final thoughts on the battery performance and the implications of the test results.

  • Japanese-made batteries consistently performed better in capacity retention and internal resistance tests.
  • The Duracell battery averaged first place across the three categories tested.
  • Chinese-made batteries finished in the last three positions, showing poorer performance.

Chapter 9

Final Remarks and Future Testing

9:58 - 33 sec

Closing statements, including a mention of future tests and an invitation for viewer suggestions.

Closing statements, including a mention of future tests and an invitation for viewer suggestions.

  • There are plans to test the self-discharge of nickel-metal hydride batteries after two years.
  • The video's content and testing ideas were inspired by viewer suggestions.
  • The creator invites more ideas for testing batteries or for other video topics.

More Project Farm summaries

Best Screwdriver Set? Craftsman, Milwaukee, Wera, Wiha, Klein Tools, Felo, PB Swiss, Tekton

Best Screwdriver Set? Craftsman, Milwaukee, Wera, Wiha, Klein Tools, Felo, PB Swiss, Tekton

Project Farm

Project Farm

A comprehensive comparison of various screwdriver brands, including their performance in driving and removing screws, resistance to cam out and failure load, handling of hammer blows, chemical resistance, and value for money.

10 Best Products Tested in 2023? Let’s Find Out!

10 Best Products Tested in 2023? Let’s Find Out!

Project Farm

Project Farm

A detailed rundown of the top 10 best products for 2023, featuring tests, comparisons, and analyses across various categories.