Why 75% of Indian Women are Unemployed
PolyMatter
16 min, 53 sec
The video discusses the unemployment crisis in India, focusing on the low labor force participation of women. It explores various factors such as cultural norms, low wages, and the lack of jobs in the manufacturing sector.
Summary
- India has an extremely low labor force participation rate, particularly among women. Only 24% of women are considered part of the labor force, and many of these don't actually work.
- The country's per capita GDP is less than $2,400, but despite the low income, India's households aren't poor enough to necessitate women working, nor are wages high enough to draw women into the workforce.
- Indian women are highly educated, but their education often doesn't lead to employment. College enrollment has increased, but women's participation in the labor force has decreased.
- Cultural expectations and personal safety issues also play a part in low female employment. India is one of the most dangerous countries for women, and women are expected to do most of the housework, leaving less time for paid labor.
- Despite similar cultural norms and poor rankings on the Women's Peace and Security Index, women in Bangladesh work at a much higher rate than those in India.
- The low wages in India are a result of the country's small businesses, which are less productive and offer lower wages. These businesses also provide fewer and lower quality jobs.
- India's economy has grown significantly, but this hasn't resulted in job creation. The country has failed to create new jobs in response to GDP growth, a measure known as the 'elasticity of labor'.
- India has a large young population, giving it potential for a demographic dividend if it can employ its labor force effectively. However, it must act quickly to avoid a demographic burden.
Chapter 1
The video starts by highlighting the high level of unemployment among Indian women, which is higher than in Saudi Arabia.
- Three out of four Indian women are unemployed.
- The labor force participation rate in India, which counts anyone looking for work, is very low, especially among women.
- Many who are technically in the labor force do not actually work.
Chapter 2
Despite having access to education, many educated Indian women are unemployed. The lack of jobs for educated women is puzzling given that better educated women are more likely to participate in the formal labor market.
- Indian women have access to education, but educated women are less likely to find employment.
- College enrollment among women has increased, but women's participation in the labor force has been declining.
- Older women are also missing from the labor force, suggesting that education does not explain the lack of female employment.
Chapter 3
Cultural expectations and personal safety issues significantly influence the employment of women in India. The expectation for women to do household chores and the danger they face in public spaces restrict their participation in the labor force.
- India is one of the world's most dangerous countries for women, making commuting to and from work a challenge.
- Cultural expectations in India dictate that women do nearly all of the housework, leaving less time for paid labor.
- The majority of Indian women eventually get married, with 90% of marriages being arranged, which can also limit their employment opportunities.
Chapter 4
Despite sharing many cultural norms and ranking similarly on the Women's Peace and Security Index, women in Bangladesh work at a much higher rate than those in India.
- India and Bangladesh rank similarly on the Women's Peace and Security Index and share many cultural norms.
- Despite these similarities, women in Bangladesh work at a much higher rate than those in India.
- This suggests that there are other factors contributing to the low rate of female employment in India.
Chapter 5
Social norms and low wages in India contribute to the low rate of female employment. Families weigh the benefits of additional income against the potential damage to their reputation and the woman's marriage prospects.
- In India, a family's honor depends on the 'purity' of its daughters, and spending time outside the home for work can tarnish this honor.
- Families must weigh the financial benefits of women working against potential damage to their reputation and the woman's marriage prospects.
- When families are poor, the loss of honor is preferable to starvation, forcing women to work. However, when wages are high, they offset the honor 'penalty', causing women to rejoin the workforce.
- India is stuck in a 'patrilineal trap' where wages are just high enough for families to survive on one income, but not high enough to draw women back into the workforce.
Chapter 6
The prevalence of small businesses in India leads to low wages and fewer jobs. These businesses are less productive, offer lower wages, and provide fewer, lower-quality jobs.
- Small businesses are prevalent in India due to tight regulations on larger employers.
- Most labor laws only apply to businesses with 10 or more employees, leading many businesses to employ fewer than 10 workers.
- The vast majority of Indian businesses are exempt from labor regulations, and many stay small to evade corruption.
- Smaller companies are less productive, leading to lower wages, less consumer demand, and fewer jobs.
Chapter 7
Despite significant economic growth, India has failed to create new jobs. The economy has grown, but this hasn't resulted in job creation, leading to fierce competition for work.
- India's economy has grown at an average rate of 6% per year since 1990, making it the fifth-largest economy in the world.
- However, this growth hasn't resulted in job creation. The number of new jobs created for every 1% change in GDP, known as the 'elasticity of labor', is effectively zero.
- If India's economy were to double overnight, employment would only increase by 4%.
- This lack of job creation has resulted in fierce competition for jobs, with many young, educated people unable to find work.
Chapter 8
India's missing manufacturing sector has led to a lack of jobs. The country has largely skipped the manufacturing step in economic development, resulting in fewer jobs and lower wages.
- Most countries have a progression from agriculture to manufacturing to services in their economic development, but India skipped straight from agriculture to services.
- The lack of a manufacturing sector has resulted in fewer jobs to absorb displaced farmers, leading to an increase in low-paid, temporary construction jobs.
- This trend is particularly detrimental for women, who are pushed out of farming but discouraged from construction. Many women have left the labor market altogether.
Chapter 9
India's young and growing population gives it potential for a demographic dividend. However, it must act quickly to avoid a demographic burden.
- India has a large and young population, with a median age of 28, compared to China's 38 or Japan's 48.
- This provides potential for a demographic dividend if it can effectively employ its labor force.
- If India can employ women at the same rate as men, its economy could grow by nearly a third by 2050.
- However, if it fails to take advantage of this opportunity, it could face a demographic burden of millions of unemployed young people.
More PolyMatter summaries
The Truth About China's Social Credit System
PolyMatter
The video explores the misconceptions surrounding China's social credit system, revealing the complexities and truths behind the media narrative.
Why it’s Illegal to Buy a Car from Toyota
PolyMatter
The video discusses the outsized presence and economic impact of car dealerships in small American towns, focusing on the example of Kellogg, Idaho.
Kim Jong-Un’s New Strategy
PolyMatter
An in-depth analysis of North Korea's new strategy and its implications for international relations, focusing on its historical context and the current geopolitical climate.
Why Spotify’s “Grand Strategy” Will Fail
PolyMatter
The video details Spotify's history, competition, growth, and challenges in achieving profitability despite being a major player in the audio industry.
Why China Banned Homework
PolyMatter
The video critiques China's abrupt policy to eliminate the private tutoring industry, exposing systemic issues in educational reforms.
Russia is Running Out of People
PolyMatter
The video outlines the severe demographic challenges faced by Russia, exacerbated by a culture of heavy alcohol consumption and poor policy decisions.