Why London’s confusing ban on junk food ads actually makes sense
Evan Edinger
12 min, 12 sec
The video discusses the banning of Ed Gamble's comedy special advertisement by TfL due to featuring a hot dog, which is against TfL's policy on promoting high-fat, sugar, or salt foods. It explores potential inconsistencies in TfL's policy and its enforcement.
Summary
- Ed Gamble's London Underground ad was banned for featuring a hot dog, which goes against TfL's anti-obesity advertising rules.
- Similar ads for products like KFC burgers and Just Eat services, which seem to violate the same rules, ran without issues, highlighting potential inconsistencies.
- TfL uses a nutrient profiling model to determine if a product is high in fat, sugar, or salt (HFSS) and therefore not suitable for advertisement.
- The host, Evan Edinger, investigates the nutrient profile model and finds that some seemingly unhealthy foods are deemed non-HFSS, while healthier options are not.
- The video criticizes TfL's policy as potentially hypocritical, given its acceptance of alcohol and vaping ads, and questions the effectiveness of the HFSS ad ban.
Chapter 1
Ed Gamble's comedy special ad was banned by TfL due to featuring a hot dog, which violates their HFSS food advertising policy.
- An advertisement for Ed Gamble's stand-up special was meant to appear on the London Underground.
- The ad was banned because it featured a hot dog, which TfL's policy prohibits due to being high in fat, sugar, or salt.
Chapter 2
TfL appears to enforce its advertising policy inconsistently, as other ads for seemingly HFSS products were allowed.
- Ads for KFC and Just Eat, which promote greasy and fatty foods, were not banned despite appearing to violate the same TfL policy.
- The video highlights the apparent inconsistency and possible hypocrisy in TfL's enforcement of its HFSS food advertising rules.
Chapter 3
The video dives into TfL's nutrient profiling model to understand how foods are classified as HFSS.
- The host describes the nutrient profiling model, which scores food based on its content per 100 grams.
- The model considers kilojoules, saturated fat, sugar, and sodium, and then adjusts the score based on fiber and protein content.
Chapter 4
Evan Edinger calculates the HFSS scores for KFC products and finds surprising results.
- Edinger calculates the HFSS score for KFC's burgers and finds that, under TfL's model, they are considered non-HFSS.
- The process reveals that a KFC veggie burger is deemed HFSS, whereas fried chicken is not, showing an unexpected outcome of the model.
Chapter 5
A comparison between a Five Guys hot dog and a KFC burger shows stark differences in their HFSS classification.
- The Five Guys hot dog has a high HFSS score, while the KFC burgers score low, highlighting the difficulty in advertising certain foods.
- Ed Gamble's ad likely faced issues due to the lack of nutritional information for the hot dog featured, unlike KFC's detailed breakdown.
Chapter 6
The video discusses other instances where TfL's HFSS ad ban has been controversially applied.
- Ads for plays featuring wedding cakes and websites promoting fresh produce with bacon were banned, despite not directly promoting HFSS foods.
- A cheese Monger's ad was also prohibited, raising questions about the cultural relevance and reasonableness of the HFSS ad ban's application.
Chapter 7
Coca-Cola circumvents TfL's advertising rules by promoting Coke Zero Sugar, which complies with the HFSS policy.
- Coca-Cola advertises Coke Zero Sugar on the Underground, avoiding the ban on high-fat, sugar, or salt drinks while still promoting their brand.
- This strategy allows Coca-Cola and TfL to maintain their advertising relationship while adhering to the letter of the policy.
Chapter 8
The video criticizes potential hypocrisy in TfL's policy concerning public health and its advertising revenue sources.
- TfL's policy seems inconsistent when considering the acceptance of ads for alcohol, which poses significant health risks.
- The video questions the impact of the advertising rules and points out the substantial deaths caused by alcohol and smoking in the UK.
Chapter 9
Edinger reflects on the effectiveness and rationality of TfL's HFSS ad ban policy.
- The host suggests that reasonable people are unlikely to be influenced by an ad to make unhealthy choices like buying a wedding cake or a hot dog.
- He argues that banning ads for foods typically not associated with immediate consumption, like wedding cakes, may not be an effective way to combat obesity.